Skip to content

Removal of Arbitrary Restrictions on Worlds in Decentraland

PassedPoll

Proposal Details

Author0x7a72…1622
PublishedSep 06, 2023 01:46
Voting beginsSep 06, 2023 01:46
Voting endsSep 11, 2023 01:46
Snapshot#c6599e6

Description

**Abstract** This proposal aims to address and reconsider the limitations currently imposed on "Worlds" within the Decentraland platform. These restrictions have ostensibly been put in place to maintain the value of land parcels within Genesis City. However, this practice contradicts the initial purpose of Worlds, which was to lower the barrier to entry and encourage a broader creator community. This proposal argues that the existing restrictions on Worlds do not enhance the value of Genesis City, and moreover, devalue the overall platform. **Introduction** Decentraland offers a unique blend of virtual real estate and content creation, providing opportunities for users to own land, create, and share content. To encourage more inclusivity and wider participation, Decentraland introduced the concept of "Worlds." Worlds were meant to allow creators to develop and share content without owning land in Genesis City. This innovative feature has the potential to invite more creators into the ecosystem, fostering community engagement and platform growth. **Problem Statement** Despite the promising prospects Worlds offer, current limitations make them less useful than they could be. These restrictions include non-accessibility or being hidden from the broader Decentraland community. These limitations ostensibly exist to preserve the value and exclusivity of Genesis City land parcels, yet they conflict with the initial intent behind introducing Worlds. **Hypothesis** The hypothesis underlying this proposal is straightforward: making Worlds less useful will not make Genesis City more valuable. Instead, it hinders the value and potential growth of the Decentraland platform as a whole. **Proposed Solution** Immediate Removal of Restrictions: Lift the imposed restrictions on Worlds in the Places dApp, to make them discoverable for all users. **Benefits** Increased User Engagement: More creators would be able to share their creations, enhancing the overall ecosystem. **Conclusion** The restrictions on Worlds neither enhance the value of Genesis City nor promote the core philosophy of Decentraland, which is decentralization and open participation. Removing these arbitrary limitations will likely result in a more engaged, dynamic, and valuable ecosystem for all stakeholders involved.

11 Comments

MonotributistaSep 12, 2023

This proposal has been promoted to DRAFT: https://governance.decentraland.org/proposal/?id=8c779150-516f-11ee-a817-7dc33a6da5df

daoSep 11, 2023

Removal of Arbitrary Restrictions on Worlds in Decentraland This proposal has been PASSED by a DAO Committee Member (0xbef99f5f55cf7cdb3a70998c57061b7e1386a9b0)

daoSep 11, 2023

Removal of Arbitrary Restrictions on Worlds in Decentraland This proposal is now in status: FINISHED. Voting Results: * Yes, allow all worlds to be discoverable 90% 7,689,146 VP (97 votes) * No, keep only worlds belonging to land owners/renters as discoverable 9% 848,125 VP (6 votes) * Invalid question/options 1% 816 VP (5 votes)

MetaRyukSep 07, 2023

I like this idea but i'm sure there are people who would want to keep it "private". What i would suggest is to make an option for LAND or WORLD owners for them to choose if they want it discoverable or "private".

ManishSep 06, 2023

I agree with this, having the scene more discoverable will always help and when i talk with medium size brands to join DCL through World, they always hesitate for a bit due to lack of discoverability.

sssssssSep 06, 2023

There is no doubt that Worlds should always be different to Lands.

MonotributistaSep 06, 2023

Totally +100. Tho indexing Worlds from non-Foundation content servers might be trickier, it may need some sort of way to integrate from the outside, while not showing the ones that are currently hidden is an extra filter on the data that is currently available, it's extra effort to get less value, to me it's a no brainer to start removing that, and we should also start thinking how we can let Worlds from other servers to also show up there.

PunkPinkSep 06, 2023

Anything that leads to more facilities and fewer restrictions for users is a good idea and in the long term if enough measures are taken it will result in greater adoption.

serenaSep 06, 2023

Currently building a world. And since it will be used for multi-media art and artists, having this scenes more discoverable its easier to pitch the idea to new users for what is possible for them.This is a great idea and will open up the doors for others. More accesability should be our goal on the platform. :brain: for it.

HPrivakosSep 06, 2023

All, including non-Foundation worlds servers.

MonotributistaSep 06, 2023

tl;dr remove this restriction in [places](https://places.decentraland.org/worlds/): ![Screenshot 2023-09-05 at 22.08.55|690x62](upload://2greUfMjfTJ4eYRbInba0M4R5t7.png)