Skip to content

Data backpack

RejectedGrant Request

Proposal Details

Author0x7534…ec57
PublishedAug 10, 2022 18:01
Voting beginsAug 10, 2022 18:01
Voting endsAug 24, 2022 18:01
Snapshot#fkreiem

Grant size

240,000 USD

Tier

Tier 6

Beneficiary

0x7534…EC57

Description

Decentralize is our Creed. We believe all data should be owned and controlled by the User. As a Decentraland User, I want to reference my data with configurable (IPFS HTTP(s), etc) URI in a data backpack. I want the data in my backpack to be available to scenes, bots, and other users as I see fit. The backpack itself could be a microchip size wearable or an actual backpack, or some other thing. I want to be able to control access to the data in my backback with the Lit Protocol. Some of my data might be composable JSON, so Ceramic data models should be available too. Lit and Ceramic are compatible with each other and with IPFS.

Voting Power

04M8MRequired to pass08/1008/1408/1708/2008/23
YesNo

7 Comments

daoAug 24, 2022

Data backpack This proposal is now in status: REJECTED. Voting Results: * Yes 1% 312 VP (9 votes) * No 99% 1,822,693 VP (56 votes)

ckbubblesAug 16, 2022

In addition to what Mattimio has suggested, we can also help you with feedback in the Community Building Decentraland Discord. We have a channel set up for people to incubate their props before posting if they like!

MatimioAug 15, 2022

I think before applying for a Grant of this size it is important to understand clearly the grant making framework itself. Here are the two proposals that established our current grant-making framework: [https://governance.decentraland.org/proposal/?id=c02ff450-2783-11ec-ac84-77607720a240](https://www.google.com/url?q=https://governance.decentraland.org/proposal/?id%3Dc02ff450-2783-11ec-ac84-77607720a240&sa=D&source=docs&ust=1660591187605911&usg=AOvVaw2DfM0RPmShmr4QHO9j_pS6) [https://governance.decentraland.org/proposal/?id=b265e3e0-bcb0-11eb-a871-a927ffd81f49](https://www.google.com/url?q=https://governance.decentraland.org/proposal/?id%3Db265e3e0-bcb0-11eb-a871-a927ffd81f49&sa=D&source=docs&ust=1660591187606083&usg=AOvVaw0FoH9Q8SqlqkDSEqkslMd3)

fhiflyAug 10, 2022

@dao is there a way to edit grants in this discourse? Is there a concept of a community grant? That seems like the decentralized approach which would probably yield the best deal for DCL community. Most people I have shared this link with though a data backpack is a good idea.

fhiflyAug 10, 2022

[quote="dao, post:1, topic:13982"] Lit Protocol [/quote] This is just an example of a cool token gate. Other token gating mechanisms should be supported.

fhiflyAug 10, 2022

@Canessa This is a first time making a DCL grant for me, so please expect the development of this Grant to be collaborative and iterative before anyone casts a vote. Please pardon my process. I don't really care "who" creates the data backpack actually. What I most care about is that it gets created. I feel like I have some valuable inputs on the subject and I am sure others do too. I did break down the expense, but please don't focus on this. Its entirely "made up" at this point, and full of assumptions, many that are probably incorrect. I acknowledge that and expect the community to help. I stated the budget at the maximum amount allowable. I budgeted FTE developer costs with an average rate for a good programmer in the US. Actual costs would vary based on the market. But I am not sure of the complexity of the implementation so I am first looking for community input from knowledgeable developer on this topic as well. Also, there can be another community organized account as the beneficiary. It does not have to go through my account. In fact I might prefer it not. Its another "placeholder" until there's a better idea.

CanessaAug 10, 2022

Hi fhirfly, You are asking for a very large sum of money. I don't see a breakdown of expenses, which is an extremely basic requirement for any grant. You also need to explain what this grant is for in much more detail for the public to understand it. Without more effort put into this it's a clear and quick NO vote for me.