Skip to content

Add a 'insufficient VP' outcome for proposals

RejectedPoll

Proposal Details

Author0x128d…9e19
PublishedJul 27, 2021 18:14
Voting beginsJul 27, 2021 18:14
Voting endsAug 03, 2021 18:14
Snapshot#WR1rAWX

Description

I recently made a grant proposal (1) that was rejected due to having less that 1 million VP in favor of it (2), while still having 80% of 'yes'. I understand that this is how the DAO is setup and questioning it is not my goal here. It just feels weird/inappropriate to be in a 'rejected' category, the same as some off-topic or bad proposals, when the outcome is 80-20. By adding an 'insufficient VP' category, it would be easier to distinguish such proposals from *truly* rejected ones. This would in turn ease the resubmitting process because I think allowing users that did not have enough VP to resubmit is ok whereas having a 95% 'no' proposal resubmitted is not relevant. We could then have something like 'this proposal is a resubmission of that other proposal'. Links: 1 : [My dashboard proposal](https://governance.decentraland.org/proposal/?id=76e8e960-e6a5-11eb-89c8-f9c6d1f05e5b) 2 : [Minimum acceptance thresholds](https://docs.decentraland.org/decentraland/requesting-grants/#minimum-acceptance-thresholds)

Voting Power

01M2MRequired to pass07/2707/2907/3007/3108/01
YesNo

1 Comments

RemyJul 29, 2021

I think you are correct that an "insufficient VP" category would be beneficial and would allow for a resubmission at a later time. They should have this.