Skip to content

DCL Community Celebration and DAO Engagement-Focused Content Creation

RejectedGrant Request

Proposal Details

Author0x153b…364d
PublishedJul 11, 2023 22:16
Voting beginsJul 11, 2023 22:16
Voting endsJul 25, 2023 22:16
Snapshot#843d3c3

Grant size

45,000 DAI

Tier

Higher Tier

Beneficiary

0x153B…364D

Description

To achieve the goal of increasing the current Decentraland communities' governance participation, the grant project will focus on two primary areas of content creation: DAO News - "The Medicine": Regular weekly recaps highlighting active grants and proposals while tracking their progress. These recaps will also report on the successful proposals that have passed, fostering transparency and awareness of ongoing governance efforts. Additionally, upcoming DAO events will be actively promoted to encourage greater participation from the community. Community Celebration - "The Sugar": In-depth creator and project spotlights will be produced, delving into the talented artists and communities that contribute to the vibrancy of Decentraland. These longer-form pieces will celebrate the achievements and contributions of community members, shedding light on their work and inspiring others. Examples of similar content can be found at: [https://www.playdcl.games/post/srjh-drawing-the-community-together https://www.playdcl.games/post/the-curation-station-reimagining-the-way-we-learn]. Event recaps will showcase the exciting events within Decentraland. These recaps will provide an overview of the events and their impact. An example of an event recap can be found at: [https://www.playdcl.games/post/mental-health-action-day]. Along with this content, I want to explore more List style content like Top 5 and Top 10 rankings. While lists are reductive and subjective, people love them. I believe that the content can be created and presented in a way that makes it clear the list is for fun and does not hurt any ones feelings while also increasing the virality of the content. I think the List style rankings will be a very effective way of making the community aware of individuals they might not otherwise be aware of. I would publish this content on playDCL.games and allow anyone within the community the right to use the content, with credit, of course. Along with the written content, I have a proven track record of being able to generate engagement within the Decentraland community and am directly responsible for a number of DCL community members having joined the DCL DAO Discord. As a member of most Decentraland Community Discords and as someone who has helped many in the community promote events for their project, I am in an excellent position to promote the DAO to the community on a grass-roots level.

46 Comments

LoadedJul 25, 2023

Why are my comments being flagged here? I don’t understand the reason.

jar0dJul 25, 2023

Thank you bot, however, this grant request is in another category.

markcumminsJul 25, 2023

The approval of a grant in the Core Unit category would depend on various factors, including the specific project proposal, its alignment with the platform's goals, budget considerations, and community feedback. Decisions on grants and funding within a platform or community are typically made through a governance process, where stakeholders, contributors, or members vote or provide input on proposals. https://katanainu.com/

jar0dJul 24, 2023

What are you accusing me of? It seems you are confused, at best.

LoadedJul 24, 2023

[quote="jar0d, post:45, topic:19773"] Look at the VP cast on this grant compared to any other, and tell me I have not already proven my ability to increase engagement. [/quote] If any of these voters are delegated by another entity other than themselves or you, which I can see many are then you cannot claim credit for their participation as they have already been incentivized to participate so using VP casted in this grant as prove of your ability to increase engagement is flawed..

MorphJul 24, 2023

As I move to be more impartial, and due to my technical experience being pretty useless here, I will not vote on this as I have limited understanding of how effective marketing works. However, it is a testament to Jar0d that he was able to garner almost 15 Million VP worth of votes total, many of which came from the community. Divisive or not, getting this much participation in a DAO vote shows a massive community presence & participation that speaks for itself.

jar0dJul 24, 2023

JasonX, You don't understand how the DAO actually works. If anything, you should be in support of me making more content, so that people like you who are unaware of how the system works have somewhere to go so they can learn. If you, a person who has been in the Foundation discord as long as you have, don't know how anything works, imagine how hard it is for noobs?

jar0dJul 24, 2023

[quote="Loaded, post:44, topic:19773"] DAO Times has put up similar proposals for this type of content and has cost the DAO way less than the amount you are asking. About 6500 USD total as far as I’ve seen. [/quote] DAO Times has no relationships with active members of the community, and has no ability to demonstrate they can increase engagement within the DAO. Look at the VP cast on this grant compared to any other, and tell me I have not already proven my ability to increase engagement.

LoadedJul 24, 2023

[quote="dao, post:1, topic:19773"] This grant aims to create content that encourages greater participation in governance, thereby fostering a more engaged community. [/quote] You need 45K USD for this? Laughable. DAO Times has put up similar proposals for this type of content and has cost the DAO way less than the amount you are asking. About 6500 USD total as far as I’ve seen. Ex. https://forum.decentraland.org/t/dao-c4f9bd8-a-dedicated-reporter-will-publish-30-articles-about-decentraland-dao-for-90-days/16418?u=loaded and https://forum.decentraland.org/t/dao-ac1518b-a-dedicated-reporter-will-publish-50-articles-about-decentraland-for-120-days/19498?u=loaded Additionally, I do not believe we should be funding someone for promotional content who easily turns to fud, insults and threats towards other community members whenever they don’t get what they were hoping for..

EibrielJul 23, 2023

Voting **Yes**, I think having some form of journalism on DCL is great. I vote yes because I think all the "[hats](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Six_Thinking_Hats)" should have a voice. That said, I don't fully agree on your way to express yourself on the Discord servers.

PixeliaGalleryJul 23, 2023

You may love him, you may hate him but the blue bird is most of the times right, his methods may not be the most popular but he is as clear as fresh water with his intentions. + he work relentlesly for DCL. I support you Blue Bird I know you want the best for DCL.

jar0dJul 20, 2023

[quote="rohoroma, post:39, topic:19773"] but this is part of content you have put forward as a reflection of your work. [/quote] That simply isn't true. [quote="rohoroma, post:39, topic:19773"] yet when a new voice joins the discussion you accuse them of being fake instead of welcoming them to the community. [/quote] It is very unlikely that a "new voice" chose this as the conversation they were going to participate in. Awkum's Razor suggests that the obvious answer is that you are a sockpuppet account.

rohoromaJul 20, 2023

The only metrics I can see is a percentage breakdown of your follower base. Can you please point me in the direction of the rest because I cannot seem to find it. It would be helpful to know how much traffic your website gets, what kind of engagement and reach you receive on your Decentraland-focused content (not engagement farming content), you mention posting across Discord servers but have not offered any indication on which ones and if they would even be relevant to your target audience. I did read the proposal. I understand that the grant would not be funding game reviews but this is part of content you have put forward as a reflection of your work. When asked for proof of readership, you have deflected or ignored. The proposal is lacking and your attitude towards it feels flippant at best, certainly not how I would expect someone to pitch to investors. You should still be holding yourself accountable. Otherwise, how are we to determine that you can actually deliver on your promises? It's my understanding the purpose of your proposal is to encourage more engagement in DAO voting and more discussion on the forum, yet when a new voice joins the discussion you accuse them of being fake instead of welcoming them to the community. It's clear you're not willing to give the answers we deserve surrounding the budget breakdown, I would have expected more due diligence.

MetaRyukJul 20, 2023

Good example of another baseless accusation. This is exactly why you do not deserve any grant. Do you think I would go down to a level where i feel the need to make an effort to create a sock puppet account to speak to you? You are truly an insult to everyone's intelligence. Stop flattering yourself...

MetaRyukJul 20, 2023

Unlike you, i have respect for their privacy instead of tagging them like you did at the other topic. Interestingly, baseless accusations is one of your specialty and an expert of. I gotta hand that over to you...

jar0dJul 20, 2023

![image|690x353](upload://hPt9VQ5fCPcs3Gepfw4MFcjjoLK.jpeg) By the way, you forgot to reply with your sock puppet.

jar0dJul 20, 2023

[quote="MetaRyuk, post:34, topic:19773"] They specifically shared that they were being harassed by you in DMs. [/quote] Who is “they” It seems that you wish to throw out the kind of baseless accusations you accuse me of. You can not have your cake and eat it top.

MetaRyukJul 20, 2023

No. This is not why others are afraid. They specifically shared that they were being harassed by you in DMs. Also, the only person that needs convincing is you. You accuse without evidence and you want people to waste their time and effort on your fruitless accusation? Stop thinking that you have the ability to influence others with your constant derogatory remarks and profanity on others. The rest are intelligent enough to know what you are doing is just throwing a hissy fit, a tantrum, desperate for attention yet desperately wanting to be seen as a savior to DCL while failing to bring down RobL that you have a huge obsession with other than just constant complaining about him on a daily basis.. Here's something that you should consider doing. Get a job. DAO is not here to pay for your rent.

MetaRyukJul 20, 2023

The rules are clear. Be respectful. That's the number 1 rule - No profanity and personal attack on the DAO server. You failed to do that and easily succumbed to your negative emotions. You are also the most muted person in the DAO server. I question your ability to be objective, unbias and composed when writing an article about Decentraland or the DAO. Also, the number of DMs i received from others sharing how they are afraid to engage on the server fearing personal attacks from you publicly and harassment privately in DMs is crazy. This is evident that you easily get personal to those who have a different opinion or disagree with you. I am appalled at the people voting Yes to this proposal given your unprofessionalism in targeting and harassing others both on Discord and Twitter. Based on this screenshot, i will modify it to reflect the current issue: Whoever is promoting, voting and supporting this proposal is supporting a harasser. . ![jaa|379x500](upload://gz6K9fOB2x9ljPFctfevZR4YLj5.jpeg)

jar0dJul 20, 2023

You should copy paste exactly what Esteban tagged me in prior to saying that. No one paying attention disagrees with my point, just my language.

jar0dJul 20, 2023

Or a minimum of 140k words. Same difference.

MetaRyukJul 20, 2023

[quote="jar0d, post:27, topic:19773"] This isn’t a grant to write game reviews. [/quote] Agreed. This is a grant to pay for your rent and your logistics..

jar0dJul 20, 2023

This isn’t a grant to write game reviews. I would encourage you to read the content included in the grant request. As for metrics, they are included, and more detailed then most grants in this category or others. Thank you for your questions.

rohoromaJul 20, 2023

According to the Grants Program, proposals in the social media category should include engagement metrics and views for the content you are putting forward as proof of concept. I am having trouble finding any of this here. I also went to look at your blog and most of your reviews are 1 to 3 sentences, is this the quality of work you are intending to get paid for? Please also provide a transparent budget breakdown, as there is a standard to be met across all dao proposals and you are not above it. If you are seeking to use DAO funds for personal expenses like rent and food and that is the only explanation you will give, then we have to maintain that this is not a suitable request from the DAO and you should seek more stable support from other resources, not the funds needed to actually boost engagement on the platform. ![IMG_3654.PNG|434x500](upload://9sG2bRLtx9yi2Xld0VKpeKzcTCq.jpeg) ![IMG_3652.PNG|303x500](upload://4Vn0edCJBV7VPWoqeGBfijQHUds.jpeg) ![IMG_3651.PNG|690x363](upload://u3YD2NE9mDoydhckeWx0wOXNc5t.jpeg) Hope you can provide more transparency and explain why you should be trusted to represent the platform.

jar0dJul 20, 2023

As I said on that proposal, I will happily say it here. I think that anyone who has actually paid attention to the ongoing discussions in the community can see that @MetaRyuk is not capable of engaging in intellectually honest or unbiased debates. He is in business with @RobL and has not been forthcoming about that fact for months while making bad-faith arguments in the defense of DistrictX and RobL. The motivation for this “report” is not to make the community better, it is to protect his investment and business partner. MetaRyuk does not care about creating a place for reasonable dialogue, if he did, he wouldn’t continue to defend RobL’s doxxing me and saying “Now that I know who you are, let the games begin” If MetaRyuk cared about a better community, he wouldn’t himself constantly be sexually harassing woman in the discord, much to the dismay of people like @DedHeadJ. @Dhingia doesn’t care about treating women with respect, if he did, he would just apologize to the transwomen he has been awful to in the community. I don’t care how much you guys love Bigots, Theives, and Conartists, I’m not going to apologize to them. I think that anyone who knows me can read what I wrote to Ney and go “Yeah, that’s how Jarod talks to his friends” Pretending that someone I’ve hosted many spaces and streams with, and exchanged 10s of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands of DMs and words it some random woman being targeted for her vote is not an honest representation of facts. The only people voting to ban me are people upset that I called out MrD for being a bigot. However, when DMing with MrD yesterday, it became clear he knows exactly why I think he’s a bigot. He is under some misguided impression that the person he knows he’s been particularly horrible to have asked me to call him out, but alas that simply isn’t the case. You are all free and welcome to embrace bigots, bullies, and thieves. I however will be fine knowing at no point did I sacrifice my integrity in order to try and claw some money out of the dao caufers.