Skip to content

Should the legacy POI list be deleted?

RejectedPoll

Proposal Details

Author0x511a…4d8d
PublishedMar 08, 2022 17:03
Voting beginsMar 08, 2022 17:03
Voting endsMar 13, 2022 17:03
Snapshot#ZSk5phv

Description

Points of Interest (or POIs) are a great way for users to explore and learn about cool places inside Decentraland. Right now the Decentraland project is maintaining two lists of POIs: - Foundation maintained list, the first implementation of POIs (Legacy POI List). - DAO maintained list, updated by the DAO Committee after a governance proposal for adding or removing a POI is approved. This **creates an unnecessary complexity** by having to maintain two lists and prevents the DAO community from removing POIs that are defined on the legacy list by using the POI Removal proposal type. On a more philosophical level, having a POI list embedded on the World Explorer (aka. Reference Client) **goes against the principle of decentralization and community ownership** of the project since another client wouldn't be able to use that list. ### A simple but expensive solution We could simply migrate all POIs from the Legacy POI List to the DAO maintained one. However the legacy list has 90 POIs, and adding all those by an on-chain transaction will have an estimated gas fee of 200 USD each, **totaling a ~$18.000 USD expense to keep those POIs** Legacy POI List: https://config.decentraland.org/explorer.json (See the [spreadsheet version](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1sdjojNKYUOLt-5v2KHnE4-9IFR5zjsUhqckRNVdNX2o/edit#gid=1503583878) with POI names) This pre-proposal Poll aims to gather community feedback on the next steps. If any of the YES options get selected, this will become a DRAFT proposal for the community to vote on.

4 Comments

NachoMar 10, 2022

Yes, we can move the list outside the Aragon infra and therefore be more effective in terms of money paid in gas fees and time. Right now, sending a tx by using Aragon is not a good UX.

ginoctMar 09, 2022

That could be a possible implementation path, having a single list and then moving it to Polygon to lower the costs associated. Is there other benefits of doing it that way?

NachoMar 09, 2022

What if we move the lists to Polygon?

daoMar 08, 2022

Should the legacy POI list be deleted? This proposal is now in status: REJECTED. Voting Results: * Yes, delete the legacy list and let the community vote for the pois that should be re-added to the dao maintained list 60% 303,568 VP (13 votes) * Yes, delete the legacy list and make the dao pay for adding the 90 legacy pois 0% 0 VP (0 votes) * No, maintain both lists 1% 22 VP (3 votes) * Invalid question/options 0% 0 VP (0 votes)