Skip to content

Does Decentraland need its own Сonstitution?

RejectedPoll

Proposal Details

Author0x247e…b418
PublishedNov 06, 2022 09:38
Voting beginsNov 06, 2022 09:38
Voting endsNov 11, 2022 09:38
Snapshot#c4ad0c8

Description

Hey Folks, I was inspired by Gino call for Decentraland Constitution ideas. "Decentralized autonomous organizations contain a particular promise: the ability to solve old coordination problems through smart contracts that encode constitutional rights. Although smart contracts are promising new tools for governance, they alone cannot govern communities; traditional constitutions and declarations of rights are still crucial for good governance." https://constitutions.metagov.org/ My opinion is that DCL needs this set of general values, rules for our community. What do you think about this ? What info should be in the Decentraland Constitution ?

Voting Rationale

0x929a…7e05No12

NO

8 Comments

daoNov 15, 2022

Does Decentraland need its own Сonstitution? This proposal has been REJECTED by a DAO Committee Member (0xbef99f5f55cf7cdb3a70998c57061b7e1386a9b0)

daoNov 11, 2022

Does Decentraland need its own Сonstitution? This proposal is now in status: FINISHED. Voting Results: * Yes 20% 615,072 VP (53 votes) * No 80% 2,414,299 VP (34 votes) * Invalid question/options 0% 0 VP (0 votes)

CheddarQuesoNov 09, 2022

I agree with @Canessa. A code of ethics would be more appropriate. >Is it appropriate to self-vote on your own proposal? Is it ethical to offer your vote if someone buys into your NFT project and you have vp? Is it ethical to use delegated vp to vote in your own best interest? Is it ethical for a few large vp holders to be able to vote in almost any proposal? NO, it is not ethical, but it is happening, and when some in the community call it out the conversation gets steered towards bullying and toxicity and trolling but these are legit questions that have been asked respectfully, and I would also like to see some accountability.

CanessaNov 07, 2022

I think we need a code of ethics. I'm not sure I'm ready to call it a constitution, but we need something. We have a lot of questions to answer as a community. Is it appropriate to self-vote on your own proposal? Is it ethical to offer your vote if someone buys into your NFT project and you have vp? Is it ethical to use delegated vp to vote in your own best interest? Is it ethical for a few large vp holders to be able to vote in almost any proposal? More than anything I think the value is in getting these conversations started.

MatimioNov 07, 2022

This will be a core goal of the DAO Facilitation Team if we continue in our operations through a second grant cycle: To help facilitate an inclusive and representative distributed constitutional drafting process, and hopefully support coming together for an IRL event as a form of a "Constituent Assembly"!

web3nitNov 06, 2022

Hey @Klockmann thanks for comment.We don't have it.

EibrielNov 06, 2022

Yes! The [white paper](https://docs.decentraland.org/player/general/whitepaper/) is super out of date. We need some new, clear, set of principles.

KlockmannNov 06, 2022

Great idea! Voting yes. But i am not sure, but don't we already have something like this? @web3nit :smiley: https://decentraland.org/terms/ ![Skærmbillede 2022-11-06 kl. 11.09.39|384x499](upload://2N98hRBGG4dkSzGFp6kEaVvcK9k.png)