Skip to content

Should we change the direction of comment posting?

PassedPoll

Proposal Details

Author0x1b35…c600
PublishedMay 10, 2024 16:40
Voting beginsMay 10, 2024 16:40
Voting endsMay 15, 2024 16:40
Snapshot#614a2eb

Description

The comment box for proposals in the DAO currently displays older comments at the top and accumulates newer comments below. This top-to-bottom publication order can be exploited by malicious actors to manipulate the opinion on a proposal by preparing comments and posting them right after the proposal is published with the intention of hiding subsequent comments, thereby nullifying or diminishing the impact of later opinions. By changing the direction in which comments are published, we can: - Prevent malicious actors from manipulating the general opinion of the proposals through pre-designed comments. - Make visible the opinions of other users who commented later.

Voting Rationale

0x5BC9…3F35Yes, change the direction of publication.30,206

Kebra Crypto Metaverse Enthusiast !

5 Comments

daoMay 21, 2024

Should we change the direction of comment posting? This proposal has been PASSED by a DAO Committee Member (0xfb1afa4dc069ffb47b19dbee196045d508fcd5a2)

PunkPinkMay 16, 2024

Thanks for doing it @ginoct, I published the poll because this change has a certain implication on the voting results, for the improvements of the DCL I continue using Canny. Thanks for your comments.

web3nitMay 15, 2024

Hey @PunkPink . Such changes require community sentiment through DAO voting but not through Canny, in which everyone with email/fb acc can post request. Lets no make DCL DAO ceremonial.

ginoctMay 15, 2024

Hi @PunkPink! As we stated several times, the best way to provide feedback regarding improvements or new features to the Governance dApp is to reach out directly to our squad (Governance Squad) via Discord, adding the piece of feedback in [Canny](https://decentraland.canny.io/governance) or creating an issue in our [repo](https://github.com/decentraland/governance/issues). I went ahead and added this as an issue in Github, here's the link so you can check it out: https://github.com/decentraland/governance/issues/1794

daoMay 15, 2024

Should we change the direction of comment posting? This proposal is now in status: FINISHED. Voting Results: * Yes, change the direction of publication. 79% 2,598,937 VP (23 votes) * No, leave it as it is. 20% 683,976 VP (16 votes) * Invalid question/options 1% 16,202 VP (1 votes)