Skip to content

Rarible Protocol <> Decentraland Integration | Stellar Gate Project

RejectedGrant Request

Proposal Details

Author0x3cb9…8f27
PublishedOct 15, 2022 03:25
Voting beginsOct 15, 2022 03:25
Voting endsOct 29, 2022 03:25
Snapshot#8d9612e

Grant size

24,000 USD

Tier

Tier 4

Beneficiary

0x0365…E0e9

Description

We, Stellar Gate, are creating a new type of FPS/RTS game within Decentraland and believe that the Rarible Protocol is needed to continue our endeavors in Decentraland. We believe this technology will also be of great benefit to all Decentraland community as it will give more power to land owners and NFT creators (whether these may be artists, game devs, etc) Rarible launched a few months back Rarible protocol. This new product allows us to integrate marketplaces in Decentraland and more. Some of the benefits are the ability to create a marketplace within DCL and sell products within DCL without the need to be redirected into another website like opensea. Land owners can even earn from fees generated by the sale of NFTs. We specially are aiming for the SDK integration on the Ethereum and Polygon networks. HPrivakos began to work on this add-on however was unable to complete it. We want to dedicate part of our personnel to the completion of this project as mentioned by HPrivakos. HPrivakos proposal: https://governance.decentraland.org/proposal/?id=691c8e60-f3c8-11eb-ab97-bfa89f33c258

Voting Power

01M2MRequired to pass10/1510/1810/2210/2510/28
YesNo

5 Comments

daoOct 29, 2022

Rarible Protocol <> Decentraland Integration | Stellar Gate Project This proposal is now in status: REJECTED. Voting Results: * Yes 1% 146 VP (19 votes) * No 99% 2,672,262 VP (64 votes)

ckbubblesOct 15, 2022

I'll defer to HP and Matts comments since it's HP's original proposal, and they both seem to understand it the most. But from what I'm hearing, it's hard to say yes on something that after 6 months may not work out. Completion competency is important for a project like this, especially when asking for a 5 figure grant.

TwenxOct 15, 2022

Hey @HPrivakos Our Devs are confident we can do this. And there's no way to give you a proof of concept without completing the entire 6 months of work. Like you mentioned in your previous comments about your attempt, it is difficult to find the time to focus 100% on the task.

mattimusOct 15, 2022

I agree with @HPrivakos about the PoC. If you need to change the browser's provider to polygon network, you will not be able to connect to dcl. Are you able to sign messages without changing networks? What aspects of the Unity Renderer will need updates? Who will maintain the transaction relayer service? Will requests be going directly to rarible or through another endpoint? Who will update the integration in case of breaking changes to rarible apis? Would this need approval from the SAB since it involves handling wallets and signing txns?

HPrivakosOct 15, 2022

Polygon is a requirement for this proposal IMO. It's listed in the specification, but I believe it's not doable in the current state of Decentraland and Rarible. I'd like to see a Proof Of Concept for transactions on Polygon from DCL (prod, not preview) before being able to vote yes on this proposal.